Loudoun County Transgender Bathroom Policy – School Board Votes to Keep Rules

The Loudoun County School Board has voted to maintain its policy allowing transgender students to use bathrooms and locker rooms that match their gender identity rather than their biological s*x. The decision came despite a request from the U.S. Department of Education to change the rule, citing potential violations of federal guidance.

In a joint statement, Board Chair Melinda Mansfield and Superintendent Aaron Spence said the district is committed to complying with applicable laws while protecting the rights of all students. They noted the Education Department believes the policy conflicts with Title IX, which has created tension between federal guidance and existing judicial authority.

Federal Pushback

In July, the Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights found that Loudoun County, along with Fairfax, Arlington, Prince William counties, and the City of Alexandria, were not in compliance with Title IX requirements. The department asked the districts to sign a proposed resolution agreement to address the concerns.

The Loudoun County School Board voted 6–3 against signing the agreement, effectively rejecting the department’s request. This decision puts the county at odds with the federal agency’s interpretation of student rights under Title IX.

Governor’s Response

Virginia Governor Glenn Youngkin has strongly criticized the Biden administration’s stance on school gender policies. Announcing the Education Department’s findings in July, he claimed that female students in Loudoun County had reported incidents of male students engaging in inappropriate behavior and watching girls change in locker rooms.

Youngkin also said there were cases where boys were reprimanded after complaining that a biological girl was allowed to use the boys’ locker room. He framed these situations as evidence of the risks posed by current federal interpretations of Title IX.

Regional Impact

The issue extends beyond Loudoun County. Fairfax, Arlington, Prince William counties, and the City of Alexandria were also named in the Education Department’s findings. Each district has been asked to respond to the proposed resolution agreement by Friday.

The Prince William County School Board recently met with legal counsel in a closed session to discuss the matter. While the board did not indicate its next steps, it released a statement emphasizing its commitment to a safe, inclusive, and respectful environment for all students and staff.

Legal and Policy Tensions

The disagreement reflects a broader conflict over how Title IX, a federal law prohibiting sex-based discrimination in education, applies to transgender students. The Department of Education’s interpretation requires schools to allow students to use facilities consistent with their gender identity. However, some court rulings and state laws have supported policies based on biological sex instead.

Loudoun County’s choice to maintain its policy leaves open the possibility of further legal disputes. Federal officials could take enforcement actions if they conclude the district is violating Title IX, while local leaders argue they are following judicial precedent.

Looking Ahead

With multiple Northern Virginia school systems facing the same deadline, the coming days could determine whether the conflict escalates into court battles. Supporters of the current policy say it affirms the dignity and rights of transgender students, while opponents argue it compromises privacy and safety.

The situation underscores the ongoing national debate over gender identity in schools, a debate that blends legal interpretation, student rights, and community values. As federal and local positions clash, the ultimate resolution may rest with the courts.

For more information on Title IX and student rights, visit the U.S. Department of Education’s Title IX page.

FAQs